Over a coke and fries
I fell in love with you.
My throat swelled up
and I stuttered.
I wish I caught your eyes.
Now it's time to go so we pay and leave
and I start to cry.
Ooh, I love you, my Forest Hills Girl.

I wasn't hungry
but I ordered dessert anyway.
I needed more time with you
before going away.
I still think of your face
every minute of everyday.
Ooh, I love you, my Forest Hills Girl.

Jon left my name on the bill
but you never called me back.
I know both our lives would be better
if you only loved me back.
Your eyes so bright.
Your smile so warm.
Ooh, I love you, my Forest Hills Girl.

My mind grows tired of living without you.
I hope you grow tired too,
please let me into your heart.
I didn't order that pickle but you broght it anyways.
Ooh, I love you, my Forest Hills Girl.

I'm sorry it won't work out,
the one love in my life.
I don't care that you're older.
I don't care if you hate me.
I love you, forever and a day.
Ooh, I love you, my Forest Hills Girl.