It's funny how time has a way of erasin' the pain
But as soon as I saw your face it all came back again
I miss those smiles, you seemed so happy to me
You said you were doing fine, had a wife and family
I had your love and I pushed it away
Now I know I made a big mistake
Silly of me¦

(chorus)
Silly of me to think that you would always be there
When I was afraid of loving you
I moved too slow and you went on your way
And now I regret the choice I made
I should be with you
I can't believe I turned away (turned away)
Should've never let you go, come back to me (yeah)

I should've never let my fear of being hurt get in the way
So afraid of lovin' you, I gave away everything
Silly of me to think that you would always be there
Heaven knows that I want you back again

(chorus)
Silly of me to think that you would always be there
When I was afraid of loving you
I moved too slow and you went on your way
And now I regret the choice I made
I should be with you
I can't believe I turned away (I can't believe that I turned you away)
Should've never let you go, come back to me

(bridge)
Now I know that things would never be
Can't believe that here's no more you and me
I'll never get a second chance
To know how it feels to hold you
And I'll never love no one but you, ˜cause I
Always wish that I had you back with me again

(chorus x3)
Silly of me to think that you would always be there
When I was afraid of loving you
I moved too slow and you went on your way
And now I regret the choice I made
I should be with you
I can't believe I turned away
Should've never let you go, come back to me

Come back to me, yeah
You were my very first love for always
I can't believe I let you go away
Come back to me¦